Most Islay whiskies pick a side. Either you are in the camp of raw, maritime peat smoke, salt, iodine and ash-grey sea, or you are drawn to the soft, fruit-heavy sherry style that smells more of Jerez than the Sound of Jura. Port Askaig Sherry Cask refuses to choose.
This is not a compromise whisky. It is a whisky that has taken its time figuring out what the two worlds can actually do for each other.
What is Port Askaig, exactly?
Here is the first thing you should know: Port Askaig is not a distillery. It is a brand.
London-based Elixir Distillers selects what it believes to be the most balanced single malt on Islay and bottles it under the Port Askaig name. Which distillery actually supplies the spirit for each release is something they never reveal. That is part of the game. Speculation in whisky circles most often points to Caol Ila, and one source confirms that the Port Askaig brand primarily sources from exactly that distillery.
The brand is named after the small village on Islay’s east coast that has served as “the gateway to Islay” for centuries, and which countless smugglers and whisky enthusiasts have sailed past over the years.
Elixir Distillers was founded by brothers Sukhinder and Rajbir Singh, who also own The Whisky Exchange. In 2022 they went further and acquired Tormore Distillery, so the “Distillers” in the name now means more than just branding.
The sherry cask: what makes it special?
Port Askaig Sherry Cask has become a permanent part of the brand’s core range, which now includes Port Askaig 8 Year Old, Port Askaig 100 Proof, Port Askaig Sherry Cask and Port Askaig 15 Year Old.
The whisky is bottled at 50.5% ABV from a small batch of 20 Oloroso sherry butts, sourced exclusively from the renowned Spanish cooperage José y Miguel Martín. It carries a UK RRP of £64.95.
Oloroso is the important word here. This is not the sweet PX style that can turn a whisky into dessert in a glass. Oloroso matures dry and oxidatively, giving nuts, dried fruit, leather and a firm tannic structure. It is the sherry type that can actually hold its own against Islay’s smoke rather than drowning it out.
Master Blender Oliver Chilton describes the casks from José y Miguel Martín as bringing distinct notes of chocolate and ginger, and a certain richness. “It’s that bit you lose your soul in as you stare into it,” he says.
The taste: what will you find in the glass?
Nose
On the nose you get smoked damson jam and blackcurrant cordial. It sounds heavy, but it is not. The smoke keeps the fruit at arm’s length and stops it from becoming too confectionery. Underneath it all there is a dry, stony minerality. The kind that typically defines Caol Ila, if you believe the speculation.
Palate
The palate offers dense, jammy fruit with coal smoke and dark chocolate-covered cherries. The 50.5% turns out to be a good call. The strength carries the flavour without burning it off, and there is room to find the layers hiding behind it.
Finish
The finish is long, with dark chocolate nibs, tarragon and dried mint. Tarragon is an unusual note in whisky, faintly liquorice-like and herbal at the same time. It reminds you that you are dealing with something that is not simply “sherry plus peat equals done”.
What does it say about the art of balance?
There is an old debate in the whisky world about what sherry casks actually do to an Islay malt. The critics say that sherry covers up the best of these whiskies: the maritime character, the mineral thread running through them, the edge that sets Islay apart from everything else.
Reviewers of older Port Askaig Sherry Cask releases have noted that the whisky’s original character can get a little lost in the sherried notes. That is a fair point, and it is exactly the problem the new release appears to have addressed. 20 Oloroso butts in one batch is not many. It is a deliberate decision to let the smoke and the sea still speak.
Chilton puts it plainly: “We want to recreate the revered, iconic Islay flavour profile of the past, and to make sure our line-up of whiskies is as balanced as the whisky itself, a refined sherry cask expression was needed.”
That is not just PR. It is an actual aesthetic position: sherry as nuance, not as makeover.
Who is it for?
The obvious candidate is the whisky drinker who loves Islay but finds the pure peat monsters a little one-dimensional after a while. Sherry Cask delivers smoke and character, but rounds it out with fruit and depth in a way that makes it approachable without being tame.
It also works well for those used to more sherry-forward whiskies like a Glenfarclas or an Aberlour, and who want to find out what peat does to the part of the equation they already know.
And it suits the season. A dark evening whisky, a glass with some dark chocolate or aged cheese alongside. Not a summer drink. A whisky that belongs when the cold has started to settle in.
A few things worth knowing
Port Askaig is non-chill filtered and free from added colouring. That applies to the entire core range, as an expression of the brand’s commitment to an unadulterated Islay whisky experience. It means you may get a little “whisky haze” if you add cold water or ice. That is normal. It is actually a good sign.
The price of £64.95 in the UK puts it in a competitive field. There is a lot of good whisky for that money. But not many whiskies solve the specific equation between Oloroso richness and Islay smoke in quite this way.
Port Askaig Sherry Cask is not the whisky that shouts loudest on a shop shelf. It is not designed to impress in blind tastings with dramatic first impressions. It is designed to get better the second and third time you open the bottle, and that is usually the sign that something has been done properly.
Leave a Reply